Case Index

PATIENT CASE STUDIES
Case 10 2/22/99 Disorders of higher function


Case discussion

Mr. X is a 70-year-old retired college professor. who is accompanied by his wife. Mrs. X is concerned about her husband’s memory. When you question her about her precise concerns, she notes that he will frequently walk into a room and forget why he has gone there. In addition his ability to recall things that have happened to him recently is diminishing. For example, his son and daughter-in-law recently visited from the East coast, and a few days afterward he asked his wife when the were coming to visit. On one occasion he went to the store to pick up a few grocery items and returned 3 hours later, unable to account for why he was gone so long. Mrs. X cannot precisely date the time she became concerned about her husband, but believes that the problems are getting worse. She thinks he may be depressed because he is less interested in spending time with friends and is losing interest in reading and going to the movies.

Mrs. X himself feels his wife is overreacting. He says that he has no concerns about his memory and that he feels fine. He is still able to manage the household finances, play golf, and work in his garden. He is able to manage all his activities of daily living. He denies feelings of sadness, sleeps well, and has a good appetite.

Mr. X has an unremarkable past history. He had an appendectomy many years ago and has had mild untreated hypertension. He never smoked, and drinks about 2 drinks of hard liquor each evening. His wife is concerned that he drinks too much. He is taking no medications. His mother died at age 72 of a stroke, his father died at age 57 of a myocardial infarction. One brother is alive and well and is 75 years old.

On examination, he has a BP of 145/90, pulse 76, and appears in good health. He is alert, knows he is in a doctor’s office but did not recall the exact address or your name. He gives the date as Tuesday, January 25, 1998 when it is in fact Tuesday, January 26, 1999. He knows that the current president is Bill Clinton, and can tell you that he was recently impeached by the House because of a "sex scandal." He can recite the presidents in reverse order back to FDR. He cannot recall any of 4 words you have given him to remember after 5 minutes, and is not quite sure that you have even given him any to memorize. His spontaneous speech is fluent, with normal comprehension, and repetition. He has some difficulty naming unusual objects — although he named a watch and pen well, he called the watch buckle "a thing for closing it" and was unable to generate the name for a shoelace. He is able to follow a three-step command. He draws simple geometric figures well.

Examination of the cranial nerves, motor and sensory system are normal. Although his deep tendon reflexes are generally normal, you cannot elicit ankle jerk reflexes. There is no Babinski sign. Cerebellar testing and gait are normal.

Pathologic Case Correlate: Neuropath Case 10


  1. Summarize the Case in 1-2 sentences.
  2. A 70 year old man presents with slowly progressive anterograde memory dysfunction and possible depression. Physical exam revealed disorientation to time, confusion, no 5 minute recall, difficulty naming objects. However, cranial nerve, motor, sensory, and cerebellar exam were all normal.

    what is the time course?

  3. Discuss lesion localization on the basis of the physical examination.
  4. Chronic, slowly progreesive disease: has degenerative or metabolic etiology

    good, lesion is likely to be in the hippocampus; note involvement of hippocampal, dorsal medial nucleus limbic circuitry in thiamine deficiency tends to cause confabulation, not seen here.

  5. Discuss underlying pathogenesis on the basis of clinical course.
  6. Inability to form recent memory and agnosia, impairment is in the following circuit: temporal and parietal association tracts that feed both the hippocampus and dorsal medial nucleus via the parahippocampal gyrus.

    good

  7. Indicate one likely clinical diagnosis. List (or classify) alternative diagnoses.
  8. Alzheimer’s disease

    Alt: Subdural trauma, normal aging (eeek!!), depression

    I do not accept normal aging as a cause of the patient's memory loss. Depression is a good alternative possiblity.

  9. Indicate 2 ancillary tests that would assist in confirming or refuting the clinical diagnosis. Indicate the test results that would confirm the clinical diagnosis.
  10. CT / MRI one would see brain atrophy, possibly enlargement of ventricles Stop EtOH and any OTC drugs memory would improve if EtOH or the OTC drugs were causing the impairment.

    clinical course; evaluation for treatable causes of dementia esp B12 deficiency would possibly refute your hypothesis

  11. Indicate complications of the disease and ancillary tests that would help evaluate them.
  12. Progressive disease with no cure. Adminstering periodic mini MSE’s that are scored will reveal deterioration.

    complications include: aphasias, apraxias, agnosias, memory loss, loss of judgement, inability to care for self, behavioral problems, increased tendency towards acute confusional states, injuries, getting lost,incontinence, pneumonias and other infections

  13. Discuss how the underlying pathophysiology is relevant in the management of this patient.
  14. The underlying pathology associated with Alzheimer’s dementia is a loss of synapses where the magnitude of synapse loss correlates with the severity of dementia. Synapses in the hippocampus are depleted early paralleling the progressive decline in memory function. There is also damage to cholinergic nuclei in the basal forebrain and acetyl choline depletion in the cortex and hippocampus. Other pathology includes neuritic plaques, (amyloid deposition), in the hippocampus and parietal cortex as well as neurofibrillary tangles (helical filaments formed by excessive phosphorylation of tau protein), within pyramidal cells of the cortex.

    Unfortunately there is no definitive treatment for Alzheimer’s dementia, but targeting the decreased cholinergic transmission and decreasing amyloid formation may hold future promise. For the patient at present, supportive treatment in the form of mental status monitoring, evaluation of depression, and family counseling are appropriate

    ok; neuritic plaques are abnormal synapses; amyloid deposition represents the deposition of what protein in the synaptic cleft? How does this protein deposit or precipitate in familial Alzheimer's disease. Are the systems involved in AD limited to the cholinergic ones? Providing support for the caretaker often a spouse is a critical part of the treatment of a patient with AD. This support should involve the counseling of the family as you say especially any adult children.

Other Version:


  1. Summarize the Case in 1-2 sentences.
  2. This is a 70 year-old retired professor whose wife describes an insidious loss of recent memory, anhedonia, anomia, and excessive alcohol intake. The duration of symptoms is not given. The patient denies that any problem exists.

    it is probably more correct to say the duration of symptoms is unclear rather than to say it is not given. good summary.

  3. Discuss lesion localization on the basis of the physical examination.
  4. Loss of short-term memory: hippocampus, limbic system, neocortex

    good

  5. Discuss underlying pathogenesis on the basis of clinical course.
  6. We're not given the clinical course, but the most likely course is a slowly progressive, degenerative course (assuming patient's wife would have noticed a sudden onset)

    youre the physician taking the hx; you asked the spouse for the time course; she "cannot precisely date the time she became concerned" when you cannot get the time course it is dangerous to assume one.

  7. Indicate one likely clinical diagnosis. List (or classify) alternative diagnoses.
  8. Alzheimer's dementia, early

    good

    - Other degenerative dementias: Pick's disease, Lewy Body Dementia, normal-pressure hydrocephalus, progressive supranuclear palsy.
    - psychiatric conditions: depression
    - Vascular causes: multi-infarct dementia, bilateral hippocampal infarcts or episode of severe hypoxia with necrosis of both hippocampi (this would have an acute onset, but since we don't know the course from the history, this cannot be excluded)
    - toxic: chronic alcoholism with
    - metabolic/nutritional: hypothyroidism, Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome, B12 deficiency, folate deficiency, disorders of liver, renal, adrenal function.
    - infectious: Creutzfeld-Jakob disease
    - neoplasia: 3rd ventricle tumors

    good

  9. Indicate 2 ancillary tests that would assist in confirming or refuting the clinical diagnosis. Indicate the test results that would confirm the clinical diagnosis.
  10. - CT or MRI: diffuse cortical atrophy, atrophy of hippocampi, enlargement of ventricles: all of these are suggestive but not diagnostic of AD
    - Folstein Mini-Mental Status Exam: score can be used to monitor progression

    Note: no definite clinical tests exist for the diagnosis of AD during life. Post-mortem examination of the brain is currently the definitive test in diagnosing degenerative dementia.

    good; an autopsy may be important in confirming the dx postmortem if you are concerned about the familial form of the disease for instance to help with counseling.

  11. Indicate complications of the disease and ancillary tests that would help evaluate them.
  12. - disability due to declining mental function -- decline in Folstein MMS score, follow-up care. This includes alteration in sleep cycles, hostility and aggression, inability to carry out activities of daily living, becoming a burden on family members.
    - medical complications: dehydration & anorexia, pneumonia, urosepsis--require good supportive care and follow-up
    - neurological complications: myotonia, gait disorders--found on follow-up
    - psychiatric complications: paranoia, depression, personality changes, hypersexuality--found on follow-up

    good

  13. Discuss how the underlying pathophysiology is relevant in the management of this patient.
  14. The pathophysiology of Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is thought to involve loss of neurons starting in the hippocampus, leading to the early onset of memory impairment , with gradual involvement of other parts of the brain, especially the entorhinal cortex, temporal cortex, and parietal cortex, with concomitant progressive loss of cognitive function. AD has been called a "disconnecting syndrome", because although the sensory and motor functions are largely intact, integration of sensations, thought, memories, and actions is impaired, almost as if each part of the brain were disconnected from the rest. The reason for the loss of neurons is unknown, but several suggestive associations have been found. First, Down's syndrome patients, who have an extra chromosome 21, tend to die early in life with dementia and postmortem brain changes indistinguishable from AD. This is thought to be due to overexpression of a protein found of chromosome 21, amyloid precursor protein (APP). Accumulations of the product of APP, amyloid-beta, are found in brains of AD patients and Down's patients at autopsy (amyloid-beta form the major component of senile plaques). This line of evidence suggests that abnormal accumulation of amyloid-beta in AD may be associated with the dementia; however, the amount of amyloid-beta accumulation does not correlate with clinical severity of disease in many cases. Another association that has been found in AD is a genetic predisposition in several forms of the disease. The epsilon-4 alleles of Apolipoprotein E gene tend to confer greater risk of developing AD at an early age. Apolipopritein E regulates lipid metabolism, and has been implicated in the pathogenesis of senile plaques. Finally, another pathologic sign of AD at autopsy, neurofibrillary tangles, are cytoplasmic inclusions within neurons which are composed of aggregates of abnormally phosphorylated tau protein, normally a component of the cytoskeleton. Again, the significance of this is not known.

    Recently several drugs have been introduced to treat the symptoms of AD: tacrine and donepezil. Both are cholinesterase inhibitors, and have been found modestly effective, returning a patient's clinical symptoms to the level of function 6 or 12 months earlier. The rationale for using cholinesterase inhibitors rests on the finding that the nucleus basalis and locus ceruleus, both important cholinergic centers in the brain, tend to atrophy in AD, leading to some of the symptoms. Cholinesterase inhibitors raise the amount of acetylcholine in the brain and restore some function.

    Antioxidants such as NSAIDs and vitamin E have been found to slow down the progression of dementia in AD, suggesting an inflammatory component which has not been elucidated to date.

    Finally, good supportive care in the form of a stable, distraction-free environment, skilled nursing care, and education for family members are important in the end stages of the disease.

    very good points: too long however